The supplication ناد علی has been recited for centuries by many Muslims, especially within certain schools of thought, as a means of seeking help and blessings through the remembrance of Hazrat Ali (RA). The phrase “ناد علی” literally means “Call upon Ali”. However, an important question arises for Muslims who want to practice their faith according to authentic sources: What is the proof of Nade Ali ناد علی کا ثبوت in Islam?
This article explores the origin, authenticity, and scholarly perspectives on Nade Ali, providing a Fatwa QA style explanation while highlighting whether this practice has evidence from the Quran, Hadith, or authentic Islamic tradition.
Origin of Nade Ali
The famous Nade Ali supplication is often quoted as:
"Call Ali, the one who manifests wonders. You will find him a helper in difficulties. Every anxiety and sorrow will vanish through his power and blessings."
It is claimed by some traditions that this prayer was taught to the Prophet Muhammadﷺ by Angel Jibreel (AS) during the Battle of Uhud, when he instructed him to call upon Hazrat Ali (RA) for assistance.
However, when we analyze this from an academic and Fatwa perspective, we must ask: Is there authentic evidence from the Quran or Hadith for this narration?
Nade Ali in the Light of the Quran
The Quran is the ultimate source of guidance for Muslims. Nowhere in the Quran is there any verse instructing believers to call upon anyone besides Allah for help. Allah states clearly:
“And your Lord says, Call upon Me; I will respond to you.” (Surah Ghafir 40:60)
This verse establishes that dua (supplication) should be made directly to Allah. From this perspective, reciting Nade Ali as a supplication directed toward Hazrat Ali (RA) raises scholarly debate, as it does not have direct support from the Quran.
Nade Ali in the Light of Hadith
Authentic Hadith collections such as Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Abu Dawood, and Tirmidhi do not contain the narration of Nade Ali. Scholars across Islamic history have highlighted that the chain of narration (isnad) for Nade Ali is weak and unreliable.
In Fatwa QA discussions, scholars often emphasize that while Hazrat Ali (RA) is a beloved and revered companion of the Prophetﷺ, and his bravery and status in Islam are undeniable, the supplication Nade Ali does not have a basis in authentic Hadith.
Scholarly Opinions and Fatwas
Different scholars have given fatwas on this issue, and opinions differ depending on the school of thought:
- Sunni Perspective:
- Sunni scholars generally consider Nade Ali as a supplication that lacks evidence from authentic Islamic sources.
- Fatwa committees often highlight that while honoring Hazrat Ali (RA) is part of Islamic love for the Ahl al-Bayt, using specific duas without proof from the Quran and Hadith is not permissible.
- Shia Perspective:
- Within Shia tradition, Nade Ali is highly regarded and recited for protection, courage, and relief in times of distress.
- Shia scholars attribute it to narrations linked with the Prophetﷺ, and Angel Jibreel, though these narrations are not accepted in Sunni scholarship.
Thus, the Fatwa QA conclusion depends on which jurisprudential perspective a Muslim follows.
Analysis of ناد علی کا ثبوت
When asking about ناد علی کا ثبوت, one must evaluate three factors:
- Authenticity:
- No sahih (authentic) hadith or Quranic verse supports Nade Ali.
- Narrations about it are either weak or fabricated.
- Theological Basis:
- Islam emphasizes direct supplication to Allah.
- Seeking intercession (tawassul) through righteous people is a debated topic, but specifically calling upon Hazrat Ali (RA) in dua has no strong textual evidence.
- Fatwa QA Ruling:
- Sunni fatwas usually discourage reciting Nade Ali as a dua since it lacks authentic proof.
- Shia fatwas allow and encourage it as part of their devotional practices.
Therefore, the proof of Nade Ali ناد علی کا ثبوت cannot be established as universally authentic across Islamic scholarship.
The Role of Hazrat Ali (RA) in Islam
Even if Nade Ali lacks strong evidence, it is important to recognize the exalted status of Hazrat Ali (RA) in Islam. He was:
- The cousin and son-in-law of the Prophet Muhammadﷺ
- Among the earliest converts to Islam.
- Known for his bravery, wisdom, and justice.
- The fourth Rightly Guided Caliph (Rashidun Caliph).
Loving and respecting Hazrat Ali (RA) is part of the Islamic faith. However, fabricating duas or attributions without proof is not encouraged in Islam.
Balanced Conclusion
From a Fatwa QA perspective, the question ofناد علی کا ثبوت must be approached with clarity and honesty:
- There is no authentic evidence in the Quran or Sahih Hadith for the supplication of Nade Ali.
- Sunni scholars do not endorse its recitation as part of authentic Islamic worship.
- Shia scholars accept and promote it as part of their devotional heritage.
- Muslims should focus on authentic duas from the Quran and Hadith, while continuing to love and respect Hazrat Ali (RA) as a great leader of Islam.
Final Fatwa QA Summary
- Keyword: ناد علی کا ثبوت
- Ruling: No authentic proof from the Quran or Hadith in Sunni sources.
- Practice: Accepted within Shia tradition, rejected in Sunni tradition.
- Advice: Muslims should rely on authentic duas but may respect cultural practices without treating them as obligatory acts of worship.
